How to Cook Crisp, Golden Mushrooms in a Home Kitchen
The first sign that mushrooms are ready to brown is often a change in sound. The soft bubbling of liquid gives way to a sharper sizzle. That is when the surfaces in contact with the pan begin to turn golden. If your mushrooms end up pale and wet, pay attention to that change before reaching for more oil or turning up the heat.
Different shapes give you different results. Tear oyster mushrooms lengthways to expose their feathery edges, which crisp nicely. Slice king oyster stems lengthways into broad pieces if you want a golden surface with a firm centre. Halve small chestnut mushrooms and quarter larger ones so each piece has a flat side to put against the pan. Thin slices cook quickly, while thicker pieces keep more bite.
If you are working with a mix of fresh gourmet mushrooms, group pieces of similar thickness before they go into the pan. A thin oyster cap can brown before a thick stem is ready. Brush off any loose debris and trim dry ends. If the mushrooms need a quick rinse, pat them dry afterwards so the pan has less water to deal with.
Give the mushrooms room
Use a wide frying pan with a heavy base and heat it over medium-high heat. Add a thin film of neutral oil, such as rapeseed. When the oil moves easily across the pan, lay the mushrooms in a single layer with space between the pieces. Put the broadest cut surfaces down first. If you have more than the pan can hold, fry a second batch while the first rests on a plate.
Leave the pieces in place long enough to colour. Lift one with tongs to see what is happening underneath. If it is still pale, give it a little longer. Once the underside is golden, turn the pieces and let the second side brown. Small, thin pieces may only need a few minutes, while thick slices will take longer. Use the colour and the sound of the pan as your guide.
Let any liquid cook away
Mushrooms release water as they cook, even when you dry them well. If you see liquid collecting, leave the pan uncovered and keep cooking until it evaporates. A crowded pan takes longer to dry out. If it is full, lift out some of the pieces and finish them in a second batch. Once you hear the sharper sizzle again, spread the remaining pieces out so they make good contact with the pan.
If the edges darken before the middle softens, lower the heat slightly and give the pieces more time. If everything stays pale after the liquid has gone, check that the pan is hot enough and the pieces are lying flat. Change one thing at a time so you can see what made the difference.
Add butter, garlic and salt at the end
Once the mushrooms are golden, turn the heat down and add a small knob of butter if you want a richer finish. Add finely chopped garlic or thyme at this point and toss briefly, just until fragrant. Garlic can scorch while the mushrooms are still browning, especially in a hot, nearly dry pan. Season with salt and pepper, then taste a piece before adding more. A squeeze of lemon can lift the flavour just before serving.
For pasta or risotto, keep a handful back and scatter them over each plate. Stirring every piece into a sauce softens the crisp edges you have just made. The same idea works with a bowl of soup or a plate of scrambled eggs. When you want the mushrooms to stay crisp for a few extra minutes, spread them out on a warm plate and leave them uncovered until you serve.
The next time you make mushrooms on toast, try cooking half the panful at a time and leaving the first side undisturbed. You will be able to see where each piece touched the pan and taste the difference between the crisp edges and the tender middle. It is the same technique you can use for a handful of chestnut mushrooms on a weekday or a plate of oyster mushrooms for friends.